© TripAdvisor 2020


American, Seafood, Steaks/Steakhouse

Dining Options

Bar/Lounge, Carry-Out, Fine Dining, Outdoor Dining, Waterfront, Open Year Round

Meal Types

Lunch, Dinner
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
$$ - $$$
#10 of 33 Places to Eat in Fenwick Island
Recent Reviews
Fast and friendly with great food.
I ordered curbside pick up, it was hot and ready at 5:30 and was delivered to my car by 5:31. I ordered the scallops in the mushroom sauce and they were perfectly cooked, and tasted great! Will...
read full review
We have been here every day
We have been here every day of our vacation. Mostly for happy hour. Everything seafood especially the oysters are so good. The atmosphere is great but the staff, especially Becca at the bar, made it...
read full review
Never disappoints!
Catch 54 is wonderful. We have been coming here for years and were glad to see that they handled the COVID summer very well. We ate here three times in August and every meal was excellent. The staff...
read full review
write a review

Catch 54

Open Today 4:30 pm - 9:00 pm
38931 Madison Ave, Selbyville, DE 19975
(302) 436-8600


Enjoy some of the best waterfront views on Delmarva while experiencing fresh Atlantic cuisine at Catch 54 by widely acclaimed chef Matt Haley.
Our newly built, two-story restaurant highlights the picturesque setting of Fenwick Island while providing a taste of coastal Delaware in a lively, casual atmosphere. Dine on locally caught seafood, steaks and more or enjoy a cocktail or bottle of wine at our expansive main or marina bars.
Catch 54 is located in Fenwick Island on Route 54, with both indoor and outdoor dining overlooking the waters of the Cove. 
Our pleasant, personable staff will ensure that you and your family enjoy your meal from start to finish. Come see why diners across the region eagerly look forward to their visits to Catch 54.
We're sorry, but we do not accept reservations.
0 0000